web page hit counter

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

A bunch of super hero comics I bought in 2008, part 2

What kinds of crazy super heroic comic books could possibly make me come about my blogging hibernation? Well, I think its safe to say that we all know the answer to that one question, now don't we.

Secret Invasion # 1. Yes. It is true. I have just read Secret Invasion # 1 and now I'm gonna throw a bunch of hate all over it 'cause how we do when we do it. Where can we start on this? From what you heard (if you have not had the pleasure of reading it) its got all kinds of your typical Brian Michael Bendis speechifying in the word balloons. And of course, its completely foreign and alien to those who have not been following along this little ride that Marvel's Golden Boy has taken the Marvel U on. This things that people say are unfalse! You can't just pick up the Bible and start reading at Revelations, my friends! You gotta get on at Genesis and see how that shit rides.

Luckily, I'm one of those morons that starting reading this Marvel Bible at the beginning. I may have skipped a couple chapters of Numbers and Deuterononmy(sp?), but I got the main picture all mapped out in my head. Something has been amiss for awhile now and today is the day that we take a moment to sort this crap out.

Having read this first issue I have decided that this isn't a very good book. Why?

Bendis can't do melodramatic. He just can't. His forte is the half-assed comedic scripting that he culled from Aaron Sorkin's assorted TV dramas and faux-cheekiness of the WB's Tuesday night line up, with the "realistic" stutter of some guy named David Mamet. Its HBO Sopranos Cool disseminated through the likes Hank Pym and Luke Cage. Every character is smart and funny, except for those who TRY to be smart and funny, only to their own mid-fight embarassment. More often than not, it is pretty damn boring.

From the moment that Iron Man opens his stupid mouth on the first page, to the shocking reveal at the end, everything comes with a self-imposed weight that does not deliver in any kind of convincing manner whatsoever. When Tony Stark tells us readers that he's telling us the biggest secret there is in the world, the eyes only roll.

We've seen this all before. It was called Civil War and it had heroes fighting other heroes. Throwing in the added bonus that some of these heroes are really just aliens in disguise makes it a little more interesting. I just can't help but think that its a premise that is not in capable hands. And that feeling seems to permeate alot of what Marvel has been putting out the past two years. These are great ideas that I could do a million times better. And I'm a horrible writer.

But I'll be around until the end, if only to give me something to hate about.

Now the new All Star Superman # 10? That's a great book. Everything that Secret Invasion # 1 did wrong, All Star Superman # 10 did right. Each page is packed with something new. We aren't just flipping through a comic book about Superman, we're turning a new corner with him. Its all ground that we have traveled before. We just have a better guide than we did last time. We have a writer that is able to make us stop and look at everything differently. This is, without a doubt, a Superman tale that will be remembered for a long, long time by fans of both super hero and non-super hero genres.

But I'm feeling like you all knew that, right? Right.

3 comments:

Jason said...

Right!

I read SI at the shop, since I couldn't bring myself to pay for it and it seems to shoot itself n the foot. It seems like they're going from a "Holy shit! Tony Stark is a skrull!" moment to a "Holy shit! Tony's not a skrull, but he's a girl!' moment, leaving the reader with nothing but a big "eh.." If nothing is what it seems, and indeed that seems to be the point of this book untilt he final reveal, why bother reading the first 7 issues, since everything will be completely fluid untilt the last page of this series, or even worse, next summer's "Secret Invasion II: Now All the Skrulls Wear Disco Suits and Have Jeri Curls!"

As for All Star Superman, that shit's the bomb.

Spencer Carnage said...

Exactly. Books like this make me happy that I read spoilers. That way I can get over it soonere.

Jonathan Nolan said...

Re: spoilers: agreed.

Also- a little thing called ROM: Spaceknight did THIS EXACT PLOT with Dire Wraiths instead of Skrulls (and the Skrulls guested anyway since Wraiths are mutant sorcery using offshoot of Skrulls). EXACT SAME PLOT. Pre-existing characters in Marvel continuity were shown to be Wraiths who had ... secretly invaded. FFS.

Also- Bendis just isn't a good writer. How comics let so few people hijack so many books is just insane.

Stan Lee he ain't.